A friend ( Oli Vickery, creative director, six black pens, www.sixblackpens.com ) recently asked me what my favourite type element was and in what typeface it was found, which got me thinking about what it is that makes you love or hate a font.
As a designer you spend a lot of thinking about which typeface will fit the brief best when you first begin any design project, whether it is a logo, a magazine or a website. You ask yourself whether it will look good in 9pt and in 84pt. Will it make your design still look fresh in two years time or will it date quickly? Are there lots of other designers already using it?
Every designer has a favourite font family. I will happily confess that mine is Helvetica, especially Helvetica Neue. I am not alone in this as it is probably the most used typeface in the world. I also have typefaces that I absolutely hate like Blur and Charlemagne. As a designer one of the great challenges you can face is making a typeface you despise work for you. One particular magazine I art directed used a display font that I hated, Gill Sans (it has the worst numbers). I worked with it for about five years until I finally managed to talk the editor into a redesign.
In 2000 I had the opportunity to be involved in the launch of a totally new magazine. It was wonderful. I spent months choosing typefaces, designing mastheads and art directing shoots. We wanted it to be really different; like nothing else in Australia at the time. I choose a typeface that I had seen in a Habitat catalogue from the UK, Din. I loved it. I used it for the display face and would have used it for the body text if I’d been able to (management decreeing that body text had to be a serif, I used Rockwell, which has great numbers by-the-way). Within two years my magazine had sadly ceased to exist (it turned out to be too cutting edge for the market at the time) but nearly every other magazine in Australia seemed to be using Din. I’m not saying that I started the trend but surely not all of those other art directors had seen the same Habitat catalogue…
Then there are old favourites that you keep coming back to. One of mine is Clarendon. I love it. It is a beautifully crafted font that looks great in upper and lower case, works as all caps, has lovely numbers and is just as good small as gigantic. I especially like it in outline, which I have used in my redesign for ‘wish’.
I think the essence of good design is good type choice, or when you can’t choose it the ability to make a pig’s ear into a silk purse. It is the difference between people who have studied design and those that have done desktop publishing courses, and it is definitely the difference between layout subs and graphic designers.